Male Lindsay Clancy juror reveals what he thinks will happen if killer mom faces a new trial

One of the three male jurors in the Lindsay Clancy mistrial believes the outcome would likely be different if the state of Massachusetts decides to retry the killer mom.

Read more Wholesale inflation rises by most in 3 months ahead of Fed interest-rate decision

The district attorney who brought first-degree murder charges against Clancy is now weighing whether to go to trial again, negotiate a plea deal, downgrade the charges, or drop them altogether after the high-stakes trial ended with a mistrial on Friday.

“I think if they tried the trial again the way they did, I think nine times out of 10 a jury would come back with not guilty by reason of insanity,” he told ABC in an interview broadcast Thursday morning on “GMA.”

“Not a doubt in my mind,” Nick Dargie told Aaron Katersky.

After a week of deliberations, the 12-member jury – composed of nine women and three men – failed to reach a unanimous verdict on whether to convict the 36-year-old Duxbury mother of murder for strangling her three kids, Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, on Jan. 24, 2023.

The jury penned a note to Judge William Sullivan on Thursday, warning that they were deadlocked and stating that “one juror refuses to listen to the law.”

Read more Lone Lindsay Clancy holdout juror did not provide ‘single piece of evidence’ to support his vote: fellow juror

Clancy’s attorney Kevin Reddington attempted to leverage this to convince the judge the lone holdout juror should be dismissed, but he declined to do so and officially declared a mistrial on Friday.

Here’s the latest on Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial:

• Kevin Reddington defends Lindsay Clancy’s ex Patrick against ‘horrific conspiracy allegations’: ‘Stop with the speculation’
• Lindsay Clancy jurors detail just what happened behind closed doors — and how a not guilty verdict nearly came down
• ‘Harsh’ Lindsay Clancy prosecution backfired, instead proving she was good mom who ‘snapped’: jurors
• Lindsay Clancy juror defends lone holdout, makes surprising admission about others on the panel

Dargie, 25, who was at first reluctant to come forward but felt compelled to explain after what he witnessed in the deliberation room, said he found the prosecution’s case “inconsistent,” and believed experts called by the defense team were “more believable.”

He was also moved by the testimony of Patrick Clancy’s mother, Susan, who spoke on behalf of her former daughter-in-law’s defense at the trial.

Read more Male Lindsay Clancy juror has emotional message for sick Patrick Clancy conspiracy theorists

“Lindsay was struggling — we were all concerned,” she told the courtroom.